Child refugees held in ‘harrowing’ conditions across south-east Asia

Report reveals young people detained in cells 24 hours a day without enough food or proper access to healthcare, often forced to sleep on the floor

A young Rohingya refugee from Myanmar is held at a detention centre in Medan, Indonesia.
A young Rohingya refugee from Myanmar is held at a detention centre in Medan, Indonesia. Photograph: Romeo Gacad/AFP/Getty Images

Thousands of children are languishing in “dangerous and harrowing” conditions in detention centres across south-east Asia, a report has revealed. Children, including babies, are being held in cells 24 hours a day, alongside dozens of unrelated adults, and are frequently separated from family members.

More than 2,290 young refugees were being held without proper access to food, adequate health facilities or education in Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia at the end of 2016, according to a joint report (pdf) by Save the Children and the Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network.

The countries are key transit routes for hundreds of thousands of refugees seeking asylum in south-east Asia and Australia after fleeing violence, poverty and conflict in countries such as Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Myanmar.

However, they are often intercepted during these journeys and treated as illegal immigrants by the authorities. They are detained for indefinite and sometimes lengthy periods without any judicial oversight, the report found.

“These children should not be treated like criminals,” said Mike Novell, Save the Children’s interim director for Asia. “The impact this type of environment has on children is extremely damaging. It can lead to developmental delays and self-harm while putting children at the very real risk of violence, sexual abuse and exploitation.”

The report, based on an analysis of immigration policies and interviews with a small number of child detainees, found young people held in “cramped and substandard conditions” were often forced to sleep on the floor or on cardboard and given “unpalatable” food.

In the most extreme cases, they were held in rooms so overcrowded that there was no space to lie down at night and fully extend their legs – or it was so hot that they found it difficult to breathe. Boys aged 12 or above were treated “as men” and children lacked privacy, were exposed to violence, and were deprived of outside space.

A boy named Elijah, who had been detained at the age of 10, told the report’s authors: “The toilets did not have any doors and in the shower they only had the tub, and where the tub was there were no walls.”

There have even been reports of some children dying from treatable illnesses due to lack of appropriate care and inadequate hygiene in the centres.

The detention of children for immigration purposes violates their rights under international law. But despite the significant human and economic costs, the undocumented detention of migrant children remains common in many countries.

In addition to the human toll, immigration detention is costly to run when compared with more humane and child-appropriate alternatives. The International Detention Coalition estimates that such alternatives may cost up to 80% less to run, as well as having many other benefits.

Evan Jones, programme coordinator at the Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network, said the devastating physical and mental impact that detention is having on refugee children is entirely avoidable. He said: “Governments across the region must recognise this unnecessary practice is not sustainable and should prioritise the implementation of alternatives.”

The charity said the relevant authorities should consider adopting community housing or – for unaccompanied children – foster care, saying the alternatives were both cheaper and more humane.

In September 2016, global leaders condemned the detention of children for immigration purposes and pledged through the UN general assembly’s adoption of the New York declaration to work towards ending the harmful practice.

The report, Unlocking Childhood: Current immigration detention practices and alternatives for child asylum seekers and refugees in Asia and the Pacific, welcomed a decline in the number of child refugees being detained by 50% since 2014.

In particular, it notes the development of small-scale initiatives in Malaysia and Indonesia by local NGOs which are supporting unaccompanied and separated children in community settings. However, the two charities insist that governments across the region must move to end child detention entirely.

In addition to those living at detention facilities, tens of thousands of children across the region are being held in other forms of detention-like conditions or have faced serious restrictions on their freedom of movement due to their migration status.

The report says these include “those confined to closed refugee camps, closed shelters, police holding cells and isolated or remote locations”.

In Australia, where nearly all children have been released from immigration detention centres in recent years, the two rights groups have called for a review of the country’s laws that still allow the practice.

Australia has a complex and elaborate legal framework for responding to asylum seekers, in particular undocumented refugees who arrive by boat. The government began transferring asylum seekers using this route to the Pacific state of Nauru in 2001.

The South Pacific island, which quickly became known as a dumping ground for the unwanted arrivals, placed refugees including children in mandatory immigration detention until changes were brought in in October 2015.

The Nauru regional processing centre is now an “open centre” and currently home to 380 people (including 45 children) who are free to come and go during the day.

This entry was posted in ASEAN, ASEAN, Child violation, Human rights - Nhân quyền, Refugee - Người tị nạn, Southeast Asia and tagged , , by Trần Đình Hoành. Bookmark the permalink.

About Trần Đình Hoành

I am an attorney in the Washington DC area, with a Doctor of Law in the US, attended the master program at the National School of Administration of Việt Nam, and graduated from Sài Gòn University Law School. I aso studied philosophy at the School of Letters in Sài Gòn. I have worked as an anti-trust attorney for Federal Trade Commission and a litigator for a fortune-100 telecom company in Washington DC. I have taught law courses for legal professionals in Việt Nam and still counsel VN government agencies on legal matters. I have founded and managed businesses for me and my family, both law and non-law. I have published many articles on national newspapers and radio stations in Việt Nam. In 1989 I was one of the founding members of US-VN Trade Council, working to re-establish US-VN relationship. Since the early 90's, I have established and managed VNFORUM and VNBIZ forum on VN-related matters; these forums are the subject of a PhD thesis by Dr. Caroline Valverde at UC-Berkeley and her book Transnationalizing Viet Nam. I translate poetry and my translation of "A Request at Đồng Lộc Cemetery" is now engraved on a stone memorial at Đồng Lộc National Shrine in VN. I study and teach the Bible and Buddhism. In 2009 I founded and still manage on positive thinking and two other blogs on Buddhism. In 2015 a group of friends and I founded website CVD - Conversations on Vietnam Development ( I study the art of leadership with many friends who are religious, business and government leaders from many countries. In October 2011 Phu Nu Publishing House in Hanoi published my book "Positive Thinking to Change Your Life", in Vietnamese (TƯ DUY TÍCH CỰC Thay Đổi Cuộc Sống). In December 2013 Phu Nu Publishing House published my book "10 Core Values for Success". I practice Jiu Jitsu and Tai Chi for health, and play guitar as a hobby, usually accompanying my wife Trần Lê Túy Phượng, aka singer Linh Phượng.

Trả lời

Mời bạn điền thông tin vào ô dưới đây hoặc kích vào một biểu tượng để đăng nhập: Logo

Bạn đang bình luận bằng tài khoản Đăng xuất / Thay đổi )

Twitter picture

Bạn đang bình luận bằng tài khoản Twitter Đăng xuất / Thay đổi )

Facebook photo

Bạn đang bình luận bằng tài khoản Facebook Đăng xuất / Thay đổi )

Google+ photo

Bạn đang bình luận bằng tài khoản Google+ Đăng xuất / Thay đổi )

Connecting to %s