A controversial article praises colonialism. But colonialism’s real legacy was ugly.

washingtonpost.com September 19, 2017 at 6:00 a.m. EDT

Women and children prepare to flee with their belongings near the Central African Republic town of Grimari on May 7, 2014. (Siegfried Modola/Reuters)

How many of today’s problems in the Global South are a direct legacy of colonialism? A recent journal article by Bruce Gilley,  “The Case for Colonialism,” kicked up great controversy by arguing that the “orthodoxy” that Western colonialism was universally harmful to colonized peoples and countries is overstated. Colonialism, Gilley writes, was “both objectively beneficial and subjectively legitimate” in many places.

Gilley, a political scientist at Portland State University, studies Chinese politics and recently made waves for resigning his membership in the American Political Science Association over its alleged lack of political diversity. His article in Third World Quarterlyhowever, ignores many existing studies that answer these questions with better data and more rigorous analysis, and which come to a resounding conclusion of “no.”

Tiếp tục đọc “A controversial article praises colonialism. But colonialism’s real legacy was ugly.”

What Is Colonialism and How Did It Arise?

CFR.org Last Updated February 14, 2023

Explore how colonialism enriched empires and fundamentally reshaped countries such as India.

A Hindu servant serves tea to a European colonial woman in this undated photograph.

A Hindu servant serves tea to a European colonial woman in this undated photograph. Source: George Rinhart/Corbis via Getty ImagesSHARE

In the late seventeenth century, the Mughal Empire controlled almost all of the Indian subcontinent.

European visitors marveled at the empire’s wealth and grandeur. Antonio Monserrate, a Portuguese Jesuit missionary, called its cities “second to none either in Asia or in Europe with regards either to size, population, or wealth.”

For centuries, merchants around the world had traveled to India, eager to trade for coveted silk, spices, and textiles. And in 1700, India’s economy was larger than all of Western Europe’s put together, making up nearly 25 percent of the global economy. By 1973, however, that number had dropped to just 3 percent. 

How did this happen?

The full story is long, winding, complex, and contentious. It involves centuries of war, technological innovation, and global trade that sent some economies soaring and brought others crashing down. But central to this story for India—and for so many countries around the world—is the history of colonialism, the practice of controlling another country or area and exploiting its people and resources.

Tiếp tục đọc “What Is Colonialism and How Did It Arise?”

World History – Lịch sử Thế giới

The Encyclopedia of World History

World History textbook @GLHS

Global Studies textbook @GLHS

Lịch Sử Thế Giới – Tập 1 – Nguyễn Hiến Lê

Lịch Sử Thế Giới – Tập 2 – Nguyễn Hiến Lê

A Concise History of the-World – An Illustrated Timeline – National Geographic – Neil Kagan

A Short History of the World – H. G. Wells